Skip to content
Shop the Sale

Prices and Availability Subject to Change. Please call 800-997-4311 for more Information.


Top-Rated Replica Pistols

Historical Emporium, selling authentic period clothing since 2003, has earned the trust of thousands of customers around the world.

With hundreds of replica pistols sold, we carefully consider customer feedback to ensure authenticity, exceptional customer care, and great prices.

We've surveyed each buyer, compiling this hand-picked list of our best-rated replica pistols.

Shop with confidence, knowing these outstanding replica pistols are customer-approved, accompanied by our dedicated five-star service and unbeatable value.


 

#1 Top-Rated Replica Pistol
1873 Colt Peacemaker Pistol Replica - Blued Finish

 Old West Replica Weapons Black Alloy |Antique Vintage Fashioned Wedding Theatrical Reenacting Costume | Lawman

ITEM 003578

$111.95

IN STOCK


   GET DETAILS / PURCHASE    
 




Reviews of this Product

Average Rating: 4.80/5.00 stars from 10 reviews

Western Event
well made would of like the product to be made in America but the quality of the product was very good and it was made in Spain.
Oct 30, 2023
Allen Osterman
Richland WA
US
1873 Colt Peacemaker
Looks and feels great. The gun’s balance is perfect for practicing fancy twirling and spinning. Real guns are not balanced for that.
Nov 24, 2022
Boxcar Bill
Moscow Oh
US
Quick draw dreams
I have an old west theme in the room I call my library. The replica is in my quick draw holster hanging underneath my Hawken 50 cal muzzleloader. The Peacemaker looks real, acts real and has the heft of it's real counterpart. My actual firearms which are not muzzleloaders are locked in my safe.
Nov 1, 2018
Joe
Kirkland Wa
US
Nice repo
Over all I'm very happy with the reproduction .45 cal Colt revolver. The minuses are: 1. The frame is just like a toy gun to pieces screwed together so the front seem is easy to spot. 2. The loading gate is spring loaded, so it will close every time you open the gate! This was not on the original. The gate will not stay open like the original, you have to hold it open with your finger. This is a little thing obviously since you can't fire it. If you buy the fake bullets they sell for the piece when you get them is the only time you will load it, so no big thing. However, I'd rather have it be like the original in all respects. This has limited use if you intend to use it in a video or film, unless it is never drawn from the holster. But it looks good, the bluing is nice and even, and the pistol looks fine in all other respects, and the grips are real wood.
Sep 28, 2016
Bill
Reseda Ca
US
Pistol Replica
I am very familiar with DENIX replicas. This is just another fine example of their craftsmanship.
Jun 7, 2014
Tony
Honolulu HI
US
Beautiful
Excellent, Beautiful replica you are just going to love and enjoy.
Jan 16, 2014
Ranger juan
Bronxville NY
US
1873 Colt Peacemaker Pistol Replica
Love it
Dec 27, 2013
Mark W Chamberlain
Roseville Ca
US
Awesome Product
These guns are great. I already owned a few others similar to this, but I'd have to say that this one is the best yet. Looks and feels real and all the moving parts work as they should. Excellent product.
Sep 12, 2012
Eric Uhinck
Beaumont Te
US
Chris V
VERY fast delivery and a truly beautiful product. I can barely put it down- odd looks at work be damned!
Jul 1, 2012
Chris Veres
Santa Barbara CA
US
1873 Colt Peacemaker
Excellent purchase. The 1873 Colt Peacemaker Pistol Replica has the feel and movement of an authentic model. I purchased this pistol to improve my accuracy with quick draw, aiming and
May 14, 2012
Anonymous


 

#2 Top-Rated Replica Pistol
1873 Colt Peacemaker Pistol Replica - Nickel

 Old West Replica Weapons Silver Alloy |Antique Vintage Fashioned Wedding Theatrical Reenacting Costume | Gifts for Him Lawman

ITEM 001735

$121.95

IN STOCK


   GET DETAILS / PURCHASE    
 




Reviews of this Product

Average Rating: 4.78/5.00 stars from 18 reviews

i love this gun
i love this gun its very nice looking looks great
Sep 27, 2024
Brian Rymill
Keene NH
US
amazing
Oct 21, 2023
Keith Rabson
CANTON GA
US
Peacemaker
Nice chrome finish Real wood handles Extraction rod really works Trigger pull smooth Easy palming action Full metal frame feels like a real gun Note: The barrel on the peacemaker does not open. That is what the extractor rod is for
Sep 15, 2022
Ken
West Jordan Ut
LOVE IT
JUST LOVE IT
May 8, 2021
James A Williams
League City Te
US
1873 colt peacemaker
Thank you Your service and the products that I purchased have far exceeded my expectations, my only hope is that your company can reach out to your vendor to see if possibly you might carry more of their inventory Thank you Best Regards Ken
Apr 29, 2021
Ken
San Mateo Ca
US
1873 Peacemaker
its a nice replica, good weight, nice to practice handling without scratching your real Peacemaker.
Nov 2, 2017
Anonymous
P
Pistol
The pistol is awesome. The only question I have is the finish that appears to have "distress" marks in the metal. If the finish should be clear and polished (such as a chrome bumper on a car) please let me know.
Apr 5, 2016
Ray
Woodstock CT
US
Excellent
Historical Emporium delivers the best product at a fair price, faster than I would have ever imagined. The 1873 Colt Peacemaker is a fine piece of craftsmanship, perfect for your best western attire or to grace any wall. I couldn't be happier with the selection. I am looking forward to many more guns to add to my collection.
Jul 23, 2015
Haygood Wryter
Louann AR
Colt Peacemaker
It was much more realistic than I expected. The weight was consistent with the actual weapon and all of the working parts were just as they should be. I was very impressed.
Feb 1, 2014
Mike
East Bridgewater MA
US
exactly what I needed
Oct 18, 2013
Anonymous

Beautiful
The 1873 Colt Peacemaker Pistol Replica - Nickel 001735 is one beautiful replica. Out of all the purchases I had made online, this was the best I have every purchased. Historical Emporium has the best product and a wonderful customer service attitude. It was so good that I bought a second Replica and hope it gets here soon.
Jun 21, 2013
Frank Vitagliano
Port Richey Fl
US
Colt Peacemaker
Good quality replica.
Apr 15, 2013
Anonymous

Nice piece of hardware
A bit to get used to,weight wise. But all in all a nice piece to practice with.
Mar 2, 2012
Matt Hallstein
Marengo IL
US
Pistol
Outstanding looks and feels like the real thing.
Jan 16, 2012
BUG
Fairfield FL
Very realistic for $80
Very good feel, nice heft and finish. Quick shipping and good customer service. A+++
Nov 21, 2011
Fish
Honolulu

 

#3 Top-Rated Replica Pistol
1873 Colt Peacemaker Pistol Replica - Gray

 Old West Replica Weapons Silver Alloy |Antique Vintage Fashioned Wedding Theatrical Reenacting Costume | Adventurer Gifts for Him Her Lawman

ITEM 001734

$111.95

IN STOCK


   GET DETAILS / PURCHASE    
 




Reviews of this Product

Average Rating: 4.76/5.00 stars from 33 reviews

Very nice.
Sep 27, 2024
June Sesoko
Pearl City HI
US
Almost too realistic
Oct 30, 2023
Carlos Evertsz
Diamond Bar CA
US
Colt Peacemaker
Looks authentic and I've had lots of compliments about it.
Oct 29, 2023
Donna Saey
Selma TX
US
Jerk that six shooter and lets see who bleeds...
Oct 13, 2023
Danielle Blake
SURPRISE AZ
US
Pistola Muy Magnifico
The Colt 45 Peacemaker is a great reproduction. The dummy bullets that I bought also fit in the gun and in the holster
Apr 29, 2022
John Davis
Chandler Te
US
Great job
The orders of the 1873 Colt six shooters was really great!! & I would love to have an old western version of a Handcuffs to put on the cowboy/Bank robbers.
May 27, 2021
Scott Fraser
Salem MA
US
1873 Colt Peacemaker Pistol Replica - Gray
Solidly built replica with functioning cylinder gate, hammer and trigger. I got mine to learn gun spinning. Heavy enough to feel like the real deal!
Apr 24, 2021
Gary A Hughes
Elk Grove CA
US
Expensive for What You Get
Denix (out of Spain) manufacturers this extremely detailed pistol so much so, it includes a supervision warning label. Almost functionally identical to the real thing with t exception of the cylinder bind up in both directions regardless of hammer position or dry firing (which they do not recommend). Pronounceable 2 position click (not four} so you can get familiar with SAA revolvers. Main issue is the hardware holding this together. The center screw on the left side of frame easily falls out getting lost with less than 50 draw back of the hammer. Be mindful of were it ends up as it is black, pointy, and sharp and worst of all, no replacement. I ended up at Home Depot getting a mini bag full of No.6, 3/4 length round head, flat tip sheet metal screws; painted the tip black since no warranty or replacement was offered. The wood grip screw will also loosen over time, just make small gradual turns to tighten is all you need. If you crank down on it, say good bye to the grips. Same goes for the side plate screw when reinstalling to tight and it's over. Overall, it's weighty, the antique finish is excellent and many will think it's the real thing up close or far away, especially holster exposing the real natural wood grips. There are plenty of youtube videos covering the Denix products.
Feb 10, 2021
FalconDriver
Dayton Oh
US
1873 Colt Peacemaker
Nice grip finish but the wood slides out of place a bit. Besides the looseness and misalignment pretty sturdy.
Jan 31, 2021
Kayla
Burbank Ca
US
1873 Colt Peacemaker
Nice grip finish but the wood slides out of place a bit. Besides the looseness and misalignment pretty sturdy.
Jan 27, 2021
Kayla
Burbank Ca
US
Excellent Replica
I could not believe the work and craftsmanship that went into this replica pistol. Very very happy with it
Oct 3, 2019
Alex Trevino
San Antonio Te
US
Peacekeeper
I love it. Good weight and feel.
Mar 21, 2019
Howard Rogers Cannon
Chesterfield VA
US
Peacemaker
Looks and feel like the real thing.
Jan 12, 2018
Jimmie G Jones
Nokesville Vi
US
Peacemaker
I bought 2, I am very happy with this purchase, these are not light weight, they have the look and feel of the real thing..
Dec 24, 2017
Jack Turner
Waipahu Ha
US
1873 COLT REPLICA
LUV IT!!! Perfect for my purpose. I just became interested in the art of, " GUN TWRILLING " Purchased 1st gun, liked the feel & size, then purchased 2nd gun 5 days later. These guns are close to the real thing as far as weight and balance. I prefer to use REPLICAS to practice with, as opposed to the REAL McCOY! The function and moving parts are close enough for EXHIBITION & DISPLAY. LOTS OF FUN!!
Nov 10, 2017
POKEY FACE STEVE
CANYON COUNTRY Ca
US

 

Your Recently Viewed Items 


Uncommon Products, Extraordinary Service

Uncommon Products,
Extraordinary Service